Let’s Talk About Marisha Pessl
Wednesday, December 13th, 2006Your reporter wonders aloud whether Marisha Pessl is pleased about the hype surrounding her debut. On the one hand there are a staggering number of reviews evoking Holden Caulfield, Huck Finn, and oddly enough, from the Boston Globe, a reference to salmon. “Lines jump out like salmon swimming upstream.” The NYTBR called it “a poetic act of will.” Vogue mentioned Jonathan Safran Foer, Dave Eggers, and Zadie Smith in a breathless sweep of the literary landscape.
SPECIAL TOPICS IN CALAMITY PHYSICS is the novel on the most lists this month. Marisha Pessl’s debut was featured in the New York Times list of notable books, triggering a fair amount of sniping.
Laura Miller’s Salon review last August was positive ( during your reporter’s relentless fact-checking, I was able to enter Salon courtesy of the Lincoln Navigator, a really big car, and a number of bouncing basketballs. I’m not certain what the correlation is between driving a Navigator and playing basketball, or if there is a correlation. For all I know there may be an entire list revealing why, after purchasing a Navigator, you may experience the desire to play zone defense.)
Here is a list of keywords from Ms. Miller’s review: Dom Delillo ( uh oh) girls, professors, frippery ( I don’t know what this word means) fascinating, surprising and wedge. Ms. Miller referred to Ms. Pessl as a novelist, the italics lending additional heft and meaning. This may be akin to calling the Lincoln Navigator a basketball player’s dream. At one point in her review Ms. Miller muses that the realm of Big Fat Books is exclusively male, implying that Ms. Pessl would not receive the recognition she deserves.
No list is bigger and fatter than the NYT’s. Ms. Pessl’s novel is on that list although not everyone is pleased to see it there. With a literary heritage that lincludes Ovid, Nabokov, Flaubert, and Flannery O’Connor SPECIAL TOPICS IN CALAMITY PHYSICS struck a chord with many critics and readers alike. This is success, my friends, with all the attendant frippery.