Why Friends Don’t Let Friends Review Books
Monday, April 21st, 2008Wellington Leg: When I was in school I shared a locker with a kid who shall remain nameless. After gym he’d rotate his sweat socks from one foot to the other in homage to personal hygiene; two months into the school year Joey ( we’ll call him Joey) smelled like a boy rotating the same pair of socks well into the Holiday Season. Joey took criticism poorly but as his locker mate I had to break the news to him. I told him he smelled bad. He punched me. I punched him back. We were dispatched to the penal colony of detention where off duty Drivers Ed commandos read aloud from the New York Post.
Via Ed Peschel I came to Tess Gerritsen’s blog wherein Tess confesses a secret: she wants to throw in the blogging towel after admitting an honest dislike for negative reviews and the reviewers they rode in on. Tess is a successful writer who has raised hackles before with her blunt talk about her frustrations with reviews, best seller lists, what some see as complaints from the penthouse.
Because of her blog I’m a Tess Gerritsen fan. I don’t review her books for the same reason I don’t review Lee Child, Barry Eisler, Harlan Coben or Michael Palmer. Those ships have sailed. And commercial success tends to drain risk taking, leaving the elements that guarantee sales dull and familiar.
I admire her quest for more than just sales and wish her luck with that. Many of the writers I find interesting and challenging are struggling to stay in print, get in print, or find some footing in publishing’s modern quagmire. They are the reason I review books even as common sense tells me not to.